Retired NYPD Sergeant SDS Joseph Giacalone kicks of September National Cold Case Month with a breakdown on national homicide clearance rates and why cases go cold in the first place. Based on his knowledge and expertise from when he was the Commanding Officer of the Bronx Cold Case Squad and author of The Cold Case Handbook 2nd Edition https://www.coldcasehandbook Joe will walks us through the many ways a case could go cold. There are many ways for it to happen. #coldcases #coldcaseinvestigation #coldcasefiles #truecrimecommunity #truecrimepodcast

The Lindsay Clancy trial has reached a critical moment as the jury deliberates the evidence, testimony, and competing arguments surrounding the deaths of her three children. On this episode of True Crime with the Sarge, attorney Franz N. Borghardt of the Borghardt Law Firm in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, joins us for an in-depth legal analysis of the Lindsay Clancy case and the questions facing the jury. With a newly added manslaughter charge now part of the case, what does that mean for Lindsay Clancy and the potential verdict? Is the jury considering murder, manslaughter, or an acquittal? We’ll break down the key legal questions, including: • Where might the Lindsay Clancy jury be headed based on the evidence presented at trial? • What does the newly added manslaughter charge mean legally and strategically? • Did the prosecution prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt? • Did the defense successfully create reasonable doubt about Lindsay Clancy’s intent and mental state? • Did defense attorney Kevin Reddington effectively challenge the prosecution’s case? • Which evidence and testimony could have the greatest impact on the jury? • What happens during jury deliberations, and what could the jury’s questions or requests tell us? • What are the possible verdicts and legal consequences for Lindsay Clancy? Franz N. Borghardt brings his perspective as a practicing attorney to help explain the legal issues, burden of proof, jury deliberations, reasonable doubt, murder versus manslaughter, and the defense strategy in one of the most closely watched criminal trials. Disclaimer: This program is for news, commentary, and educational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. All defendants are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in a court of law. Lindsay Clancy Trial Verdict Watch: Did Kevin Reddington Create Reasonable Doubt? 00:00:00 Introduction to the Lindsay Clancy trial and jury deliberations 00:00:24 Introducing guest attorney France Bogart 00:00:46 Discussing why the jury was not sequestered 00:01:31 The impact of Dr. Aaron Mack's resignation during deliberations 00:05:54 Comparing the Clancy case to the Bronx postpartum psychosis verdict 00:17:51 Evaluating the defense's best moments and strategies 00:21:42 The impact of having nine female jurors on the panel 00:31:16 Analyzing the prosecution's strengths and tactics 00:41:01 Interpreting 10 hours of jury deliberations and potential outcomes 00:50:24 Broader national conversation on postpartum mental health and true crime discourse Subscribe to True Crime with the Sarge for expert interviews, criminal investigations, cold cases, breaking true crime news, courtroom analysis, and conversations with former law enforcement officers, attorneys, investigators, journalists, and other experts. #LindsayClancy #LindsayClancyTrial #LindsayClancyVerdict #TrueCrime #juryverdict #Manslaughter #MurderTrial #ReasonableDoubt #KevinReddington

🚨 ROLL CALL IS IN SESSION! Retired NYPD Detective Michael Alcazar joins Joseph Giacalone on True Crime with the Sarge for an in-depth look at three major true crime cases making headlines. We break down the Lindsay Clancy case wrap-up, including what happened in court, the key issues surrounding the case, and what comes next. Then, we turn to Bryan Kohberger, as a judge grants new hearings in the case. What do these hearings mean for Kohberger’s defense, the prosecution, and the road ahead? We also examine the case of Andrew Dykes, who is accused in the death of Tanya Jackson, formerly known as “Peaches” on Long Island. Dykes’ defense team has asked the judge to throw out the murder charge. We’ll examine the defense argument, the prosecution’s case, and what could happen next. Join retired NYPD Detective Michael Alcazar and Joseph Giacalone for Roll Call, where we go beyond the headlines and break down the evidence, courtroom strategy, investigative issues, and legal developments shaping today’s biggest true crime cases. 🔎 Topics Covered: • Lindsay Clancy case wrap-up • Lindsay Clancy trial and latest developments • Bryan Kohberger new hearings • Bryan Kohberger defense strategy • Andrew Dykes case • Tanya Jackson “Peaches” murder case • Long Island crime and investigations • Defense motion to dismiss murder charge • Criminal investigations and courtroom strategy • Retired NYPD detective analysis Subscribe to True Crime with the Sarge for true crime investigations, cold cases, breaking case updates, interviews with detectives and experts, and behind-the-scenes insight into the criminal justice system. 00:00:00 Welcome and Happy Face Killer Identification 00:01:31 Lindsay Clancy Verdict Predictions and Discussion 00:13:30 John Jay College Memories and Shoutouts 00:16:20 Healthcare and Mental Health System Discussion 00:30:26 Jed York Arrest Analysis 00:32:05 Andrew Dykes and Tatiana Jackson Case Updates 00:39:53 Bryan Coberger Hearing and Legal Strategy 00:43:57 Ohio Child Services Case Review 00:54:10 Viewer Questions and Closing Remarks #lindsayclancytrial #bryankohberger #andrewdykes #truecrimepodcast #truecrimecommunity

What happened to Nancy Guthrie? In this special episode of True Crime with the Sarge, Fox News Digital investigative reporter Michael Ruiz joins me and Josh Zeman to discuss his boots-on-the-ground investigation into the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie from her home in Pima County, Arizona. Mike was there from the beginning of the investigation, reporting from the scene and following developments as investigators worked to determine what happened to Nancy. He brings a firsthand perspective on the search, the investigation, the evidence and unanswered questions surrounding this high-profile missing person case. In this episode, we’ll discuss the Nancy Guthrie disappearance, the investigation in Pima County, the search efforts, the background of the case, what Mike witnessed and reported from the ground, and the latest developments that could help shed light on where the investigation stands today. 🔎 Topics include: * The disappearance of Nancy Guthrie from her Arizona home * What happened in the earliest hours of the investigation * Mike Ruiz’s boots-on-the-ground reporting from Pima County * The search for Nancy and investigative efforts * Key developments and unanswered questions * The background of the Nancy Guthrie case * What investigators may be looking at as the case continues * The latest updates and where the investigation stands Join me for an in-depth conversation with Mike Ruiz as we take a closer look at one of the most closely watched missing person investigations in Arizona. Subscribe to True Crime with the Sarge for true crime investigations, missing persons cases, cold cases, breaking crime news, law enforcement analysis and interviews with investigators, journalists and experts. 00:00:00 Introduction and Guest Welcome 00:01:36 Tucson Manhunt vs. Nancy Guthrie Case Connection 00:03:26 The Investigation at 203 Days and Monsoon Season Landscape Shifts 00:05:30 Task Force Breakdown, Private Tech Companies, and FBI Involvement 00:07:21 Crime Scene Handling, Gilgo Beach Comparisons, and Mistakes Made 00:15:23 Ransom Notes, Cryptocurrency, and Crypto Hacker Theory 00:18:48 Blood Evidence Inside the House and DNA Mixture Samples 00:22:08 Wild Theories, Homeless Suspects, and Imposter Ransom Notes 00:25:26 Press Conferences, Media Collaboration, and Crowd Reaction 00:29:55 Tips Submissions, Encrypted Comms, and Digital Forensics 00:32:25 Urgency Levels, Video Surveillance Database, and Ring Cameras 00:41:41 Forensic Genetic Genealogy (IGG/FGG) and Law Enforcement Standards 00:45:10 The Reality of Being an Investigative Journalist 00:48:22 YouTubers, Social Media Impact, and Protecting Good Samaritans 00:51:50 Emerging True Crime Cases and the Lindsey Clancy Trial 00:54:19 Million-Dollar Rewards, Anonymous Tips, and Final Thoughts #NancyGuthrie #NancyGuthrieMissing #NancyGuthrieDisappearance #MissingPerson #MissingPersons #ArizonaCrime #PimaCounty #TrueCrime #TrueCrimeWithTheSarge #MikeRuiz #FoxNews #CrimeInvestigation #MissingPersonInvestigation #TrueCrimeNews #LawEnforcement

🚨 ROLL CALL IS BACK! Retired NYPD Detective Michael Alcazar joins True Crime with the Sarge for an in-depth look at some of the biggest criminal justice stories making headlines. We’ll break down the Penn State cocaine trafficking ring bust, where authorities have charged 14 people, including current and former Penn State students, in an alleged operation involving two off-campus fraternity houses. We’ll examine what investigators uncovered, the alleged roles of the suspects, and what this case tells us about organized drug distribution on college campuses. We’ll also have the latest Lindsay Clancy murder trial update from Massachusetts. As the defense presents its case, testimony is focusing heavily on Clancy’s mental state, postpartum psychosis, alleged medication issues, and whether she was criminally responsible for the deaths of her three children. In addition, we’ll dive into the Keefe D trial out in Los Angeles for the shooting of Tupac Shakur and where the case is possibly headed! Plus, Michael and the Sarge will break down other major true crime, police, and criminal justice stories making news across the country. 🔎 Topics include: * Penn State cocaine trafficking ring and fraternity drug bust * 14 people charged in the Penn State investigation * How the alleged cocaine operation worked * Lindsay Clancy murder trial and the defense strategy * Postpartum psychosis and criminal responsibility * Key testimony and evidence from the Clancy trial * Law enforcement analysis and investigative perspective * Other major true crime and breaking crime stories Join Retired NYPD Detective Michael Alcazar and the Sarge for another edition of ROLL CALL, where we go beyond the headlines and examine the evidence, investigative tactics, and criminal justice issues behind today’s biggest cases. Subscribe to True Crime with the Sarge and turn on notifications so you don’t miss the latest interviews, case updates, investigations, and true crime analysis 00:00:00 Roll Call Intro and 3-Year Channel Anniversary 00:01:22 John Bitrolff and Long Island Serial Killer Connections 00:12:02 Lindsay Clancy Trial Updates and Legal Arguments 00:37:06 Tupac Shakur Trial and Dwayne "Keefe D" Davis Case 00:47:07 Penn State Cocaine Ring Breakdown #TrueCrime #RollCall #MichaelAlcazar #PennState #PennStateCocaineRing #LindsayClancy #LindsayClancyTrial #TrueCrimeWithTheSarge #NYPD #CrimeNews #CriminalJustice #TrueCrimeNews #Police #Investigation

Luigi Mangione has pleaded guilty in federal court to stalking charges in the killing of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson, admitting in court that he shot Thompson in Manhattan on December 4, 2024. Federal prosecutors are seeking a life sentence, with Mangione’s sentencing scheduled for December 18, 2026. (AP News⁠) Now comes the bigger legal question: What does the federal guilty plea mean for Mangione’s New York state murder case? On this episode of Roll Call on True Crime with the Sarge, I’m joined by Associated Press investigative reporter Mike Sisak, who has been covering the Mangione case from the courthouse and reporting on the stunning developments leading up to this week’s guilty plea. We’ll break down: • What happened behind the scenes leading up to Mangione’s federal guilty plea • What Mangione admitted to in federal court • Why prosecutors are seeking a life sentence • The significance of the federal plea for the New York state murder prosecution • Mangione’s defense motion arguing double jeopardy should prevent the state case from continuing • Whether the state murder case could be dismissed • What Manhattan prosecutors are likely to do next • What happens if the state case moves forward • How the federal and state cases differ • What Mangione’s December 18 federal sentencing could mean • What comes next for Luigi Mangione and the prosecution of the killing of Brian Thompson Mike Sisak brings firsthand reporting and investigative insight from the Associated Press as we examine one of the most closely watched criminal cases in the country. Watch this episode of Roll Call for the latest analysis of the Luigi Mangione guilty plea, the federal case, the New York state murder case, double jeopardy, sentencing, and what happens next. 00:00:00 Introduction and guest welcome 00:00:27 Atmosphere of the courtroom on Friday 00:01:28 Luigi Mangione's behavior during the hearing 00:02:32 Defense strategy regarding double jeopardy 00:03:15 New details on the stalking charges 00:04:47 How Mangione gained information on the conference 00:06:46 Family reaction and statement 00:08:38 Issues with the timing of the state indictment 00:10:49 The circus-like nature of the proceedings 00:12:13 Double jeopardy arguments explained 00:15:01 Federal versus state prison conditions 00:17:49 Reactions from the public and Mangione supporters 00:19:42 The impact on corporate security 00:21:43 The gamble of the guilty plea 00:26:02 Federal sentencing guidelines 00:28:42 Defense team's successes and strategy 00:32:46 Changes in executive protection and security 00:36:14 Growing trend of political violence 00:38:35 Lack of family support in court 00:42:25 Future cases on the reporter's watch 00:44:32 Frequency of dual prosecutions 00:47:24 Speculation on the state case outcome #LuigiMangione #BrianThompson #UnitedHealthcare #TrueCrime #RollCall #TrueCrimeWithTheSarge #MikeSisak #AssociatedPress #FederalCourt #GuiltyPlea #DoubleJeopardy #NewYork #CrimeNews

Join True Crime with the Sarge for a compelling conversation with acclaimed author Hillel Levin, author of Submerged: A Cold Case, An Innocent Man Condemned, and One Family’s Darkest Secret. What happens when a murder investigation goes horribly wrong, an innocent man is condemned, and a family’s darkest secret remains buried for years? In this special episode, Hillel Levin takes us deep into the true story behind Submerged, exploring a mysterious cold case, a wrongful conviction, the investigation that failed to uncover the truth, and the secrets that helped keep that truth hidden. We’ll discuss the evidence, investigative decisions, courtroom battles, unanswered questions, and the painstaking search for what really happened. Levin also shares the reporting and research behind the book and what this case can teach us about wrongful convictions, cold case investigations, police investigations, forensic evidence, criminal justice, and the search for justice. 🔎 Topics include: * The cold case at the heart of Submerged * An innocent man condemned for a crime he did not commit * The investigation and evidence that led authorities in the wrong direction * The family secret surrounding the case * Wrongful convictions and investigative failures * How cold cases can be reopened and reexamined * What investigators can learn from cases like this * Hillel Levin’s research and reporting behind Submerged * The unanswered questions that still surround the case If you are interested in true crime, cold cases, wrongful convictions, criminal investigations, murder investigations, investigative journalism, criminal justice, and real-life mysteries, this is an episode you won’t want to miss. Watch, subscribe, and join the conversation on True Crime with the Sarge. #TrueCrime #TrueCrimeWithTheSarge #HillelLevin #Submerged #ColdCase #WrongfulConviction #TrueCrimeAuthor #CriminalInvestigation #MurderInvestigation #ColdCaseInvestigation #CriminalJustice #InvestigativeJournalism

Bryan Kohberger is back in the legal spotlight, and the case surrounding the Idaho College Murders is far from over. On this episode of True Crime with the Sarge, I’m joined by Angenette Levy of the Law&Crime Network, a veteran journalist who has closely covered the Bryan Kohberger case and the murders of University of Idaho students Kaylee Goncalves, Madison Mogen, Xana Kernodle, and Ethan Chapin. (CrimeCon⁠) We’ll break down the latest developments surrounding Kohberger’s effort to challenge his guilty plea, including his new legal representation, the motions being made by his defense, and what his claims could mean for his conviction and sentence. A new attorney was appointed to represent Kohberger in his effort to withdraw his guilty plea. (Spokesman-Review⁠) We’ll also examine the ongoing investigation into alleged evidence leaks connected to the Idaho murders case, what investigators are looking into, and why those leaks could have significant legal implications. (Fox News⁠) In This Episode: • Bryan Kohberger’s latest legal motions • His new attorney and changing legal strategy • Kohberger’s attempt to withdraw his guilty plea • Claims involving his former defense team • The investigation into alleged Idaho murders evidence leaks • What the latest developments could mean for Kohberger • The University of Idaho murders and the continuing legal fallout • Expert analysis from Law&Crime’s Angenette Levy • What happens next in the Bryan Kohberger case Angenette Levy has covered some of the nation’s most high-profile criminal cases and has extensively followed the Bryan Kohberger and Idaho student murders investigation. (CrimeCon⁠) Subscribe to True Crime with the Sarge for true crime investigations, breaking case updates, interviews with detectives, prosecutors, attorneys, journalists and experts, and an inside look at the cases making headlines. 00:00:00 Introduction 00:00:37 Bryan Kohberger's New Psychological Evaluation and Post-Conviction Filing 00:02:18 Orchestrating the Media Narrative 00:05:09 Defense Losses and Legal Challenges in Ada County 00:08:21 The Role of Expert Witnesses and the Brent Turvey Controversy 00:12:11 Critique of the Plea Agreement and Missed Opportunities for a Proffer 00:18:22 Questioning How Kohberger Navigated the Crime Scene 00:20:26 The Impact of the Sy Ray Interview and Potential Retrial 00:26:38 Analyzing Kohberger's Diagnoses and Arid 00:29:55 The Impact on Victim Families 00:32:07 Mishandling of the Crime Scene and Evidence 00:36:45 The Dateline Evidence Leak and Criminal Investigation 00:44:31 Could a Continuance Have Prevented This? 00:47:17 Amazon Purchase History and the KBAR Sheath 00:50:50 Lack of Blood Evidence in the Elantra 00:55:05 Internet Searches and Car Detailing 00:58:33 Looking Ahead: What's Next for the Case #BryanKohberger #IdahoMurders #UniversityOfIdaho #AngenetteLevy #LawAndCrime #TrueCrime #TrueCrimeWithTheSarge #Kohberger #KayleeGoncalves #MadisonMogen #XanaKernodle #EthanChapin #TrueCrimeNews #CrimeNews #IdahoMurdersUpdate